Updated from the original article published July 15, 2020
Finding the right expert witness is more than identifying someone with impressive credentials.
Attorneys must consider whether an expert’s experience aligns closely with the facts at issue, whether the expert can communicate complex information clearly, whether there are conflicts or credibility concerns, whether the expert is available within the case timeline, and ultimately whether the expert is the right fit for the engagement.
An attorney or law firm may already know an excellent expert. In some matters, that existing relationship may produce exactly the right candidate. But highly specialized litigation often requires expertise outside a firm’s established network. That is where a broader expert witness search can become particularly valuable.
The challenge is not simply finding an expert. It is identifying and evaluating the right expert witness for the specific matter.
A familiar expert can be an excellent starting point. But familiarity should not be confused with fit.
Every matter presents a different combination of technical issues, industry experience, jurisdiction, deadlines, damages questions, and communication demands. An expert who was an excellent fit for one case may not necessarily have the precise expertise required for another.
This becomes especially relevant in specialized areas such as engineering, pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, intellectual property, technology, economics, finance, and other highly technical disciplines.
| “The process of finding experts has evolved, and I think for the better. When I first started it was largely a process of asking my client if they knew anyone. Asking my partners at the law firm if they knew anyone.”
— Stephen Chappelear, litigation attorney |
That traditional referral process remains useful. The problem arises when it becomes the entire search. Limiting candidate identification to prior relationships, internal recommendations, directories, or general online searches may unnecessarily narrow the field before the attorney has had an opportunity to compare candidates.
In complex litigation, broad subject-matter knowledge may not be enough.
The specific issue in dispute may require an expert with experience in a small subspecialty, a particular technology, an uncommon methodology, or an industry practice from a specific period.
| “Relevant experience is the first thing I look for in an expert. The second relates to knowledge. It matters to me that the expert is credible. The last piece is someone who has the sort of strength to tell me, ‘No, I disagree.’”
— Teena-Ann V. Sankoorikal, commercial litigator |
That last point is especially important. The best expert is not necessarily the candidate most willing to support a particular theory. Attorneys also need an expert with the independence and confidence to identify weaknesses, challenge assumptions, and stay within the limits of their expertise.
Candidate identification and expert witness vetting are different tasks.
Once a potential expert is identified, attorneys still need to evaluate issues such as:
The objective is not simply to identify someone whose résumé looks impressive. It is to understand the candidate well enough to make an informed retention decision.
An expert may have extensive education, publications, professional recognition, and decades of experience and still not be the right testifying expert for a particular matter. Attorneys also need to consider whether that individual can translate technical knowledge into clear, defensible testimony.
| “When thinking about getting an expert I look at three things. First, are they truly an expert in this area? The second is, are they going to be persuasive? The third is credibility.”
— Matthew Morr, trial attorney |
Subject-matter expertise gets an expert into consideration. Communication, credibility, independence, and case-specific fit help determine whether that expert should ultimately be retained.
A specialized expert witness search firm can expand the candidate pool beyond the attorney’s immediate network. Rather than relying solely on previously retained experts or publicly listed candidates, a targeted search can reach professionals in academia, industry, research institutions, professional organizations, and highly specialized technical fields.
This is particularly valuable when:
The benefit is not replacing counsel’s judgment. It is giving counsel a stronger pool of candidates from which to exercise that judgment.
Even when attorneys are capable of conducting their own expert research, there is another consideration: Is searching the best use of their time?
A comprehensive expert witness search can involve identifying disciplines, researching candidates, reviewing credentials, determining interest and availability, checking potential conflicts, communicating case requirements, and coordinating preliminary interviews.
Outsourcing candidate identification allows the litigation team to stay focused on pleadings, discovery, depositions, motions, case theory, and trial strategy while the expert search proceeds in parallel.
For more than 30 years, Round Table Group has helped litigators identify and connect with consulting and testifying experts across specialized academic, scientific, technical, financial, medical, engineering, and industry disciplines.
The process begins with understanding the matter and the expertise counsel needs. Candidates can then be identified for the attorney to review, interview, compare, and ultimately decide whether to retain. The attorney remains in control of the selection decision.
There is no charge for Round Table Group’s expert witness search and no obligation to retain the experts presented.
If your next matter requires specialized expertise, start your expert witness search or call 202-908-4500.
Attorneys can find expert witnesses through prior professional relationships, colleagues, clients, academic institutions, professional organizations, expert directories, online research, legal research platforms, and expert witness search firms. For highly specialized matters, a broader search can help identify candidates beyond the firm’s existing network.
Relevant subject-matter expertise is only the starting point. Attorneys should also evaluate the candidate’s credentials, experience, prior testimony, publications, communication skills, availability, potential conflicts, credibility, independence, and ability to explain complicated issues clearly.
Expert witness vetting is the process of examining a potential expert’s background before retention. Depending on the matter, this can include reviewing credentials, licenses, publications, prior testimony, litigation history, professional disciplinary history, publicly available statements, conflicts, and other information that could affect the expert’s suitability or credibility.
Possibly. A previously retained expert may be an excellent candidate when their expertise matches the issues in the new matter. However, attorneys should evaluate each engagement independently rather than assuming that a successful expert from one case will automatically be the strongest candidate for another.
A search firm can be especially useful when the required expertise is highly specialized, the firm’s existing network does not produce the right candidates, an expert has a conflict, the attorney needs several candidates to compare, or case deadlines make an extensive internal search impractical.
There is no charge for Round Table Group’s expert witness search and no obligation to retain the experts presented.
Attorneys can submit the matter through Round Table Group’s Request an Expert Witness page or call 202-908-4500.