We recently had the chance to sit down with Richard D. Williamson, a leading commercial and complex civil litigator who heads his own practice (Robertson, Johnson, Miller, and Willamson) in Reno, NV. Richard and his partners focus primarily on commercial real estate and have represented clients in jury trials, bench trials, arbitration hearings, mediations, and more.
During our conversation we discussed situations in which Richard seeks expert witnesses from a commercial real estate perspective. Additionally, we explore the importance of testifying experience and whether academic experts are the right fit in his field.
The interview has been edited lightly for length and clarity.
One thing I enjoy about commercial real estate is it really is so broad. And so, we will have everything from a landlord-tenant dispute for a shopping mall or a strip center to construction disputes, easements, boundaries, and all sorts of things. There really is a wide range within that. The need for experts then varies depending on the case.
For instance, in a construction type dispute, I think with few exceptions, an expert is almost always going to be necessary. Even in a contractual dispute with a contractor, [regarding] whether or not they abided by the standards in the industry, you’re going to need a contractor to really speak to and help define what those standards are.
Whereas in just a breach of lease case, where a tenant vacates a property early before their lease term is up, is often just a matter of very simple arithmetic and simple calculation of what the remaining lease term is. So that will not always require an expert, but there can be times where the damages are really difficult.
Or, for instance, if there’s a really long-term lease still to play out, it’s possible you may need some sort of a leasing expert to talk about when it would be anticipated a new tenant could get in there and help reduce or mitigate those damages. So [expert witness needs] vary on a case-by-case basis [depending] on what the specific subject matter is and how much an expert is needed [to address it].
I think it is generally helpful to have someone at least with past testifying experience. Now an expert starting out is going to have to testify for the first time somehow. So, [testifying experience] is not always required, but it can be helpful getting an expert qualified to be able to render expert opinion testimony at trial, [and] so the expert knows what to expect; a deposition will not be new to them or testifying in court and the formalities and procedures will not be new to them.
Now, there are occasions when it still will be. For instance, you may have a really good construction expert who was a construction practitioner for many, many years, that’s where the bulk of that person’s experience is. Maybe [they are] in retirement or after that person sold their business, they have now shifted into a more expert witness role. It’s possible they’ve testified as a fact witness or as a party in a prior case, but, it’s also possible that while they are a perfectly fine expert, they just haven’t testified. So, I don’t think that’s a deal-breaker necessarily. But I do think it can be very helpful to have past testifying experience to some extent.
I suppose it’s possible that there can be cons to having too much, and appearing like a hired gun to have testified in court a million times. Sometimes experts are almost too polished and do not seem genuine. But to me, that’s really more of a testifying skill that that expert needs to work on to not appear so slick. Not how much or how little they’ve testified, but more just their kind of approach and delivery.
If someone was really good and really fit the bill, and I felt reasonably confident that they could project themselves well and come across credible at deposition and at trial, it’s not an automatic excluding factor if they don’t have past testifying experience.
Whether it’s a contractor, a real estate broker, maybe a surveyor, usually we’re looking to practitioners as our experts that have that kind of practical, real world experience. But yes, there are times when we have used academics and really, I think sometimes it’s almost needed. The one that jumps to my mind is an economics professor to provide some level of damage analysis. An economist that might be able to help calculate a client’s damages from various things that require some careful analysis. Some of those subject areas really don’t lend themselves to practical real-world businesses that someone would just hire that person to do.
We found that in those areas academics are sometimes the best and often the only source of expert witnesses. And so, yes, there are definitely specific subject matters and specific situations where it really helps to have an academic.
The role of broker is to help facilitate transactions between buyers and sellers, typically involving a commission. This expertise spans multiple industries including insurance, information, auto transport, real estate, IP, finance, and more. Our broker experts have experience working in all of these industries as brokers, consultants, appraisers, professors, lenders, property managers, and advisors.
Commercial real estate includes office buildings, retail space, multifamily apartments, undeveloped land, and other nonresidential properties (ie. stadiums, airports, hotels, medical facilities, self-storage spaces, etc). Our commercial real estate experts have been retained to provide opinions on contracts, valuation, liability, investments, building management, and more.
Our construction expert witnesses, speakers, and consultants are scholars and researchers from major universities as well as professionals in the construction industry and nationally recognized consultants and testifying experts. They have extensive experience with residential, commercial, and industrial projects; clients include business owners, developers, attorneys, manufacturers, marine contractors, oil companies, design professionals, public and government agencies, sureties, insurance companies, school districts, construction contractors, and others.
Real estate is property consisting of a piece of land, along with its buildings and natural resources. The term “real” means real or physical property. Residential, commercial, industrial, and land are the four types of real estate.
Real estate appraisals are an important part of the home buying, selling and refinancing process. During the home buying and selling process, real estate appraisals are used to establish if the home’s contracted price is correct after considering the home’s features, location, and condition. In a refinancing situation, real estate appraisals reassure the lender that they are not giving the borrower more financing than the home is worth.
The most popular class of real estate is Residential Real Estate. This class of real estate contains housing for individuals or groups of people for daily living. Residential Real Estate consists of single-family homes, condominiums, townhouses, duplexes, high-value, and vacation homes. New construction and resale homes are considered Residential Real Estate.