Public Health Expert Witnesses
Public health questions surface in commercial litigation whenever a company's products, operations, or policies are alleged to have affected health outcomes across a population rather than for a single individual. Manufacturers, marketers, employers, health systems, insurers, and government contractors can all face claims that depend on epidemiological evidence, disease surveillance data, or the adequacy of prevention and response measures. Such matters include coordinated product litigation brought by public entities, disputes over infection-control and outbreak-response obligations, reimbursement and program-funding conflicts, and regulatory enforcement actions. The central issue is typically whether reliable population-level evidence supports the alleged link between conduct and harm, and whether the defendant acted consistently with accepted public health practice at the time.
Public health experts help counsel test the scientific foundation of those claims. Much of that work centers on study design and data quality, including whether observational studies adequately control for confounding, whether surveillance data were collected consistently, and whether an observed association satisfies accepted criteria for inferring causation. Experts can also evaluate the guidance, standards, and program practices that governed a party's conduct, which matters when liability depends on the reasonableness of a marketing campaign, a workplace protocol, or an institution's response to an emerging threat. Where public entities seek abatement costs or program damages, biostatisticians and health policy specialists can scrutinize how population harms were attributed and valued. That analysis frequently supplies the basis for Daubert challenges and for rebutting opposing experts who stretch general findings to reach specific conclusions.
Public health encompasses epidemiology, biostatistics, health policy, communications, and environmental and occupational health, and the expert best suited to a general causation challenge may be quite different from the one needed to evaluate an institution's regulatory compliance. Our network includes epidemiologists and biostatisticians who have published on infectious, environmental, and occupational disease; health policy specialists who have testified on Medicaid and Medicare funding and reimbursement systems; and practitioners with backgrounds in communicable disease control, threat preparedness, and CDC-certified infection control. Many publish extensively on subjects such as air quality standards, injury control, and drug policy, belong to organizations including the American Public Health Association, the Society for Prevention Research, and the Society for Clinical Trials, and have testified in both federal and state courts. With more than 75,000 expert searches completed for litigators, Round Table Group understands how to align that depth of experience with the precise question before the court. We welcome the opportunity to discuss your public health matter by calling us at (202) 908-4500.