Control Expert Witnesses
Control systems govern how plants, machines, vehicles, buildings, and supply chains behave, and when they fail, the resulting commercial disputes can involve enormous operational and financial losses. Refiners and chemical producers sue automation integrators after advanced process control upgrades destabilize units or miss throughput guarantees, manufacturers pursue suppliers of motion control and robotics systems that fail acceptance testing, and building owners challenge HVAC and energy management controls that never deliver promised savings. The concept of control extends into management as well, with disputes over project cost and schedule controls on large construction programs, quality control in manufacturing and mortgage underwriting, and internal and operational risk controls in financial services. In each, the central issue is whether a control system or control process was properly designed, implemented, and maintained to achieve its stated objectives.
A control expert evaluates that issue by reconstructing how the system or process was supposed to work and comparing that design with what actually happened, using controller configurations, tuning parameters, historian and event data, quality records, or project control documentation. In a process control dispute, the analysis may show whether loop tuning, model predictive control design, or alarm management caused an upset; in a construction dispute, it may test whether earned value, change management, and schedule controls met accepted project management practice. The expert then addresses causation by separating failures in the control design or implementation from equipment limitations, feedstock changes, owner decisions, or other external factors. Those findings support breach, warranty, and performance guarantee claims, frame the measure of lost production and cost overruns, and allow counsel to rebut an opposing expert's account of how the system should have performed.
Control spans process, motion, vehicle, flight, and building systems as well as management, quality, and project controls, so selecting an expert begins with identifying which kind of control the dispute actually concerns. Members of our network have served in leadership roles with the International Federation of Automatic Control, including its Technical Committee on Process Control and its Coordinating Committee on Industrial Applications, and the experts we present include chemical engineers specializing in nonlinear process control and advanced control of refining and power generation processes. Others bring expertise in robotics, embedded control, and manufacturing automation, along with a construction management expert who has testified on changes and schedule delays and worked on a nuclear power plant delivered on schedule and on budget, and a mortgage quality control specialist who has testified on underwriting compliance. With more than 75,000 expert searches for litigators completed, Round Table Group can help you find the control expert your matter requires. Tell us about your case by calling us at (202) 908-4500.